
See Part 1 of this series, on the runners-up for my top ten list, here. Tomorrow I’ll post Part 3, on my favorite undistributed/yet to be distributed films of the year, and then Part 4, on my films of the decade.
This is actually a top 12, for reasons to be explained within.
10. Inglourious Basterds
9. The Hurt Locker
8. Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans
7. The Limits of Control
6. Cargo 200
5. Beeswax
4. Summer Hours
3. The Girlfriend Experience/The Informant!
As far as I’m concerned, this was the most impressive year of Steven Soderbergh’s career, and his two 2009 releases are inextricably linked. I just wrote a story about this, will insert a link here when it’s published.
2. Two Lovers
1. Silent Light & Frontier of Dawn
Because of confusion regarding what constitutes a theatrical release (5 days or 14 days? In a traditional movie theater, or as part of a festival put on by a museum?), I named two different films on the indieWIRE and Village Voice polls. I knew Silent Light was not eligible for the Voice poll, because its 5 days at MoMA made it eligible for their poll in 2008, so on that list I named Philippe Garrel’s Frontier of Dawn as my favorite film of the year. Because that film played only 5 days at BAM before IFC released it on VOD, I thought it wasn’t eligible for the indieWIRE poll, which stipulated in the rules that a film must screen theatrically for a full week, so I chose Silent Light, which did 2 weeks at Film Forum in January. Whatever. They’re both masterpieces.

People have been asking me where they can find my lists of the best (or, really, more accurately, my favorite) films of the year and decade. I thought I had pimped these pretty extensively when they went up at ToNY and indieWIRE, but hell, I’ll post them here too, just for the chance to add extra bullshit/context.
First, since I already used my Tumblr to shout out my runners-up for best films of the decade, here, in alphabetical order, are my honorable mentions for best films of 2009, with links to relevant things I’ve written about them where applicable.
35 Shots of Rhum, Avatar, Fantastic Mr. Fox, The House of the Devil, I’m Gonna Explode, Julia, Medicine for Melancholy, Night and Day (above), The Road, Tetro, Valentino: The Last Emperor, The Windmill Movie.